I
“You said you would tell me. Now either tell me or I’m leaving. Some of us do actual work, you know, besides seducing women—has that ever occurred to you? ” said Ed, in his lopsided smile, as if his lower half were being permanently tortured but he had gotten used to it. “So what is this ‘humiliating thing’ that you invented?”
“People don’t invent humiliating things about themselves, and I said I would tell you if you’ll just shut up for six seconds.” Two middle-aged English professors in a coffee shop near campus—Ed (who is too tall for his width) in his white button-down shirt and slacks looking, as usual, like a crazed accountant; Bark, in his flannel shirt and jeans. The place was full of dark insinuating coffee smell and the machine-gun rasp of bean grinders and the usual self-satisfied conversation.
“Look,” said Ed, “when you start up about women, not once—“ (a bright, shiny day in New England after a solid week of rain…) “—Not once have you told me about your actual failures, which must be innumerable. The evidence all says that you’ve dragged me here on false pretexts just to brag about one more, historic, earth-shaking triumph! And what do I need that for?”
Bark shrugged. He smiled and tipped himself back in his chair. “Don’t fall again for god’s sake!” said Ed.
“Thanks,” said Bark. “But it was ten years ago. It couldn’t still be a triumph. Well maybe for you it could, because your triumphs come every ten years, but I mean for a normal guy. Anyway you’ve said I’m a liar, so why should you listen?” He was hanging back, mulling, enjoying Ed’s torment. “And of course I slept with her. But that wasn’t the point.”
“It’s always the point, just like murder is always the point. Fine. So: another chapter of Professor Levmore gets his girl. Write the book, what are you waiting for? Kill us with your ingenuity.”
”I have no ingenuity. I’m an English professor.”
II
Barkley C. Levmore, with his long, dark face, dense mustache and eye crinkles could have been a seafaring man from New Bedford. But he was only from New Jersey and had played professional baseball for two and a half seasons, culminating in seven unspectacular weeks with the Pittsburgh Pirates. “Unspectacular” was his word. For all anyone knew, they might have been devastating.
He and Ed were old friends at the same English department at a top university, where everybody walked around with an imaginary 18k gold star on their foreheads. Tension was taut between them. They voted against each other on appointments and promotions. Each was a formidable scholar in his own right. Each imagined his own loyal band of graduate-student followers who hated each other. Ed’s followers are intensely-concentrating scholars leaning forward so as not to miss a syllable, thinking Ed as the Last Defender of the Last Standard. Bark’s followers think of him as a desert warrior galloping with raised scimitar on a noble steed, peeping through the cloth scarfed round him, with four naked rescued slave girls planted right behind him. In fact, the grad students, as in many universities, do all of the work and get excised from the department as soon as they start to forge an actual contest to the older men that have been entrusted to maintain the institution’s eminence.
“I’m sorry I called you a liar,” said Ed. “I brought you a quote, by the way.” He pulled his phone out of his pocket.
“‘William Smith wrote to a Yale classmate in the mid-eighteenth century contrasting his virtue with rakish vice. Their ’highest Ambition is to Saunter through a Coffee-house—to spend their Days in Idleness, and their nights in frothy and fulsome Compliments among falsely so called Ladies.’ It’s a book called The Heart of a Man, by Lisa Wilson. It’s about you, Bark!”
“Everything’s about me, isn’t it?” he said in his wise-sea-captain way, that would have driven people crazy if it weren’t self-parody.
III
“Just a sec,” said Ed, and he went to the counter and got himself another coffee and one of those huge Post-Modern Muffins it takes three men to lift. (Bark’s joke.) Ed can consume ten million calories at a gulp and it only makes him hungrier, and thinner. This annoyed Bark, who is not severely fat, though with his average height and broad shoulders appears to be fat easily.
“Now eat your muffin and I’ll tell you your bedtime story,” he said. “If you can keep yourself under control. Maybe you ought to just read it yourself. Can you read?”
“Better than you can write.” Gangly Ed always gives the impression that his pants are too short. His stubble always shows through his pale skin and, always, that dumb shirt. And wild thick dense black hair. But his dark eyes blaze and spark so strikingly that people figure he is brilliant before he has even opened his mouth. Brilliant or dangerous.
“Okay,” Bark said. “There is a lady in the case, so I will ask you, respectfully, to tone down your ordinary vulgarity—if you can.“
His eyes gradually sharpened, not on Ed but on some point in the distance. His voice became deep and carefully shaped and mahogany as he let his mind beat itself into the past.
“Whatever you call it,” he says, “honorable failure, heartbreaking failure, failure with a cruel resemblance to success—I never tried it again.
IV
“She crouched on her heels, with one knee on the ground, balancing a large book on her lap with grainy black-and-white photos. She was in a library aisle on the mezzanine. It smells like big rolls of fresh, new carpet in a large department store, as if no one had ever seduced anyone on this carpet before. A foam-rubbery smell, light and innocent, like my childhood bedroom. It was five minutes until closing.”
“Just happened, huh.”
“Nothing just happened.” Bark sounded almost angry. “I told you: eighth try. I constructed this situation by careful planning and, above all…” Some word was about to emerge but he seemed to lose heart. He glanced listlessly out the window and shook his head.
“Girls want to be seduced—by some men, but you’ve got to do your part. The young guys you find in the locker rooms—these morons talk as if the girl is supposed to seduce herself While-You-Wait…if she doesn’t jump into the guy’s lap and demand fast, meaningless sex while she sings, dances and strips for him all at once, he’s incensed. But face it,” smiling at Bark—“self-seducing girls are decades away. Not in our lifetimes, old man.” He reached across to pat Ed on the shoulder. “I mean, even a girl who asks herself out to lunch, for god’s sake, is way beyond the state of the art.”
Ed had a slow but friendly half-smile, as if correcting Bark’s attitude was not worth the trouble, because Bark was hopeless.
Bark had explained earlier his scheme for seducing a woman “in place.” It was something he had conceived as a teenager and had tried occasionally as a college student, but had found hard to bring off.
The “almost successful” event he’s describing happened ten years ago in a public library in Westchester near the Hudson. He wanted somewhere public but quiet, with sheltered nooks so you could easily outwit the guards and stay behind after closing.
“She was in tight jeans and black suede shoes,” he continued, “And a dusky pink cotton sweater with an elastic, soft V-neck, and softly puffed sleeves. This soft elastic at the neck is just what you want to pull gently aside, to expose her shoulders. She had straight darkish-blonde hair, that curled inward along the bottom.”
“Small waist, narrowish hips,” Bark continued; he can go on describing women until hell freezes over. “Lovely, articulate bare neck and throat with a single tiny diamond on a gold choker at the level of her shoulder blades; the eloquent chords of her neck bunching forward in a narrow V when she leans towards me, with the diamond chip nestling at the base. And small earrings, bright blue enamel and gold.”
“Do you memorize every woman you look at?”
“Yes.”
She is around 23. She had “pretty ankles which suggested that her knees would be pretty too.” She looks at the world quietly, with a smile or a laugh or a giggle waiting in the wings at the corners of her mouth. Her features are neat and fairly small, and you might have called her just routinely pretty except for that held-back laughter.
The library’s main hall is a large lofty cube. The front has a row of tall sash windows looking west. Partway back, the mezzanine cuts the cube in half—upper and lower.
“And it was one of those large, empty, solemn summer days,” he adds, “Try as I might I still can’t believe any summer will ever end.”
V
“It’s short for Thomasin.”
“How could anything,” said Ed, “be short for Thomasin. It’s such an obscure name, do you really believe that it finally got eroded into nicknames by the Anglo-American population over the centuries?”
The woman’s name, by the way, is Tamsin—Bark pronounces the first syllable to rhyme with Sam. He then goes on for ten minutes about what a wonderful name this is.
VI
“So I was at the end of her aisle, up in the mezzanine,” he continues, “where no one ever goes anyway—and I crouched to talk to her, friendly: ‘please could you help me? It’s an experiment.’
“She lingered on her photo for a moment and then looked up. Her movements are so quick and her whole face and body are so alive, it’s like she has twice the pulse of a normal person. So she says: ‘An experiment in getting kicked out of libraries? You know it’s about to close.’”
Bark tells Tamsin that the details of this experiment don’t matter, the main thing is that they both have to stay for a few minutes after closing time. He shows her a letter purporting to “authorize” the experiment, and swears up and down that if they get caught, he’ll insist that the fault was all his.
“But the real experiment,” Ed says, “correct me if I’m wrong, was to establish whether you could nail her right then and there before she even knew what hit her.”
“No,” said Bark. “It was total freedom. To see whether two people could meet and make love on the exact same spot, then part forever—an experiment in lived poetry, for both of us. Ultimate total freedom.” He closes his eyes. “Okay. I admit, it was one of the stupidest things I’ve ever done in my life.” (Yet he looked inspired, as if he were pondering with deepest admiration some noble feat of heroism far above his own level that he had read about as a child.)
“I was young,” he added, “and at least I can understand what I was getting at.”
“Thirty-five is young?”
“In my case.” Bark looked at a passing car. “I knew nothing. Did you know anything when you were thirty-five?”
“I’m not sure I know anything now.”
VII
An hour later, Bark and Tamsin have somehow got to the point where she is gently resting her forehead on his forehead.
Twenty minutes later her back is against his side, his thick arms loosely around her. The shadows are long. It’s twilight. They have talked enough for Bark to know that she’s well read, obsessed with Shakespeare and Donne and Keats and Byron and Shelley, but has come to think of them all as luxuries not to be over-indulged in; she had dedicated herself to reading books about economics, but hasn’t yet got through a single one.
“All I have to do is love something,” she said comfortably, confidentially, “and immediately I feel myself going overboard. I feel guilty about it while it’s happening, which is crazy.”
“I don’t think that’s crazy.”
“Maybe not. But it’s not good. I take things too seriously. Myself included. And even if it’s a good thing, I would still feel guilty about it.”
“You can go be a nun.” Half his mouth raised into a smile. “You’re so small you’d look like a walking curtain.”
“That’s the thing.” She paused to think. “Even something like that. If somehow I learned to love martyring myself for mankind, I would immediately feel guilty about enjoying it so much. I would keep doing it, all the time, but I would try to stop right away. I wouldn’t—I mean, I do what I like, but my conscience is fascist to me.”
“You should ask Freud what he thinks. Do you read Freud?”
“Yes,” she said, “shouldn’t I?”
“Sure you should, you’re ridiculously learned!”
And she answered, with mock thoughtfulness, as if she were tentatively proposing a complex philosophical formulation at which she had recently arrived—“Do you think, professor, that your being just in the middle of—I mean, how should I put it—with one hand on my waist and the other casually resting on my…left breast, as if I might not notice if you don’t; as if—I love how men do this—as if it just ended up there by itself,” (He was laughing), “and all you can do is shrug and apologize—do you think this all might have just something to do with your opinion about my learned-ness? Have you noticed that men appreciate girls’ minds especially much when they’ve got their hands under their blouses?”
He repositioned his hands, grasped her upper arms. He looked her straight in the eyes: “I’d admire you and listen to you,” Bart said, “even if you were a man, God forbid, or a child, or a geranium. But what you are is the loveliest girl in the universe, and I won’t pretend that’s irrelevant, because there is loveliness in everything you say and do.”
She laughed. “Why shouldn’t the plural of blouse be blice?”
Bart put her back where she had been and wrapped his arms around her from behind.
“You don’t even know me,” she said. Bart was kissing her hair and her neck. “You don’t even not know me...” Ten minutes later she is speaking again.
“So what do you expect to do with me? You can’t undress me here.” There was a shrug in her voice.
“No, I won’t undress you right here. I have another plan.”
There was a big pair of all-chrome scissors on an upper shelf, and a roll of duct tape.
He said to her, “I only want to adjust your outfit a little.” And she said, in deliberate innocence, “So you’re going to cut my clothes to shreds?” and I said “no, just an adjustment, I’ve always been a couturier at heart.”
Ed is outwardly-disapproving, inwardly-grinning Ed.
“You see,” Bart explains, “my God, if only you were wearing shorts. I presented my evidence,” he’s saying to Ed, “for exactly why I believed in her legs. Why I believed that her legs, although tragically hidden at the moment, were in fact spectacular. I alluded to the loveliness of her skin—and specifically the shapeliness of her arms and the elegance of her ankles…
“She’s leaning back against me so we aren’t looking at each other—because I don’t want to embarrass her—or rather I do want to, she wants to be embarrassed this way, but I don’t want to make her self-conscious. Unless that is part of the teasing. I’m talking into her herbalized hair, and I’m explaining that it’s fair to generalize from her arms and her ankles to her legs, because as a rule the quality of a young lady’s bones is constant.
“And the poor woman says, ‘I have pretty bones? Now tell me about my hair follicles.’
“Anyway—I was cutting off the lower part of each leg of her pants. I told her, ‘I’ll staple you back together. There must be staplers in libraries. Otherwise I’ll tape you back together. And I will of course send you a new pair.’
“‘You’re the soul of generosity,’ she said. Then: ‘You’re giving me awfully short shorts’—touching her front with her fingertips, tucking stray hairs behind her ears as she looks at my activities down below. She laughed and I barely heard it.
“Then I shuffled around behind her and reached down and cuffed up the left leg once, then twice, which was getting a bit tight—and then three times. The cuffs were pinching into her inner thigh. She looked back at me. ‘I can help you.’ And she cuffed them even higher and tighter, until there was no place left to go. I took her around the waist.
“I pulled aside, at last, her elastic neckline, down over her shoulder, feeling the absolute softness of her upper arms. She followed my mouth with her eyes, and then met my mouth with hers.
“The cut-off lengths of pants were waiting to be pulled off, and I pulled down the left—she rocked her knee back off the floor and I pulled it down below the knee—then the right. I did not want to take them off completely. I did not want her to look naked—not yet. I wanted her undressed. So she was not a wonder of nature but a beautiful, vulnerable woman.
“I had to enjoy the sights and sounds and feel of her, had to handle her—I’m behind her kneeling and she’s kneeling too—
“I was running both my hands gently downward, close together, towards her knees, then at her knees, then back up. The surface so immaculately smooth and coolish, the substance so yielding, beyond soft; ethereal.
“Of course I needed more, so I moved aside to face her. Her pant legs were bundled around and beneath her knees. I held her unveiled left thigh with one hand while I examined the gold button between her hipbones and undid it with my fingertips. I held each side and eased off her modified pants. Her bouncy hips and thighs were freed. I pushed the shorts down to below her knees. Her lavender, satin panties were exposed.
“Nothing compares to the tactile perfection of gently sliding a girl’s panties off. The sheer magnitude of the satisfaction—why don’t we thank God for that? For the tiny minimum—and yet non-zero—of muscular effort it takes to slide off a girl’s panties?” I pushed them to just below her knees.
“And then I stood—‘I’m off to fetch things to make us more comfortable, you stay here.’
“She was sitting back on her thighs now, looking at a library card, the kind they used to have in a pocket at the back of each book, and then she held it loosely between her bent fingers, gesturing with it as she talked. Then she raised herself on her knees again to expose her ass, pressing the card to her breast with both hands, symmetrically—the two opposite curves of her gently-pressing hands, patiently waiting. But I just flipped her hair a little—and headed off.
“I told her all the doors were locked; I’d checked. Then I went back to the meeting room in the basement. I found half a bottle of sherry and an unopened bag of cookies and a nearly-full box of slightly stale but perfectly edible chocolates. And Styrofoam cups.
“I brought it all upstairs and she was sort of gesturing with her hands around her head, as if it she were measuring for a hat. The elegance of her knuckles, the smallish, lovely, speaking hands—every square inch of her was articulate. ‘A hat would complete my outfit,’ she said. ‘Any top hats down there?’
“‘I can’t tell you how lovable and gorgeous you look,’ I said.
“‘You picture us this way all the time, don’t you?’ Her voice suddenly with an edge and coolish. ‘I mean men in general and girls in general. You see through our clothes. Picture us naked. Picture yourselves fucking us. Right?’
“‘I pay all sorts of attention to women’s clothing and it means a lot to me. It’s all so complex.’
“‘Okay. But that’s not really what you care about. You look at girls in ordinary situations, and picture us naked.’
“‘Sometimes, sure. Of course. That’s just normal. It’s not on purpose. It’s not planned. Not even intentional. Not—exactly.’
She smiled, indulgently. And drily. A bit drily.
VIII
“We were side-by-side, embraced. She was naked except for her gold chain and diamond chip. She had taken off her earrings, precisely and delicately cupping her hand below each ear, releasing the latch with her fingertips and nails, catching it in her palm, reassembling it—and handing it to me. (Her purse was beyond arm’s length, but I was convenient.) I thrust the earrings down deep into the pit of a pants pocket. Now my arm was behind her back pressing her against me. I kissed her lips and neck. The softest skin, silent inhale, then that softest moaning exhale.
“I ease us down onto my jacket spread on the floor. Slowly. Slowly. As if I were dipping her in a dance and she is so close to weightless—the drapery of her hair falling behind her, except for some strands caught on her shoulders.
“Then very deliberately she shut her mouth and turned her head and said, ‘I don’t think this is a good idea.’ Quick phrases, alongside short gasps. ‘I’m telling me, not just you.’
“So—I told her I had a condom. That sentence I spoke, I have a condom, should be engraved in huge letters on a marble wall in the Men are Stupid memorial somewhere near the Washington Monument, which should be thronged day and night. And have a gift shop.
“‘No,’ she said. It seemed that she was about to say more. But instead she shook her head and relaxed back into my arms.
“After a moment she added, ‘I say it because I like you.’ I said ‘I don’t understand’ in my cajoling gentle voice and went back to kissing her and she went back to kissing back and being kissed, and that was that.
“She wound up afterward curled up against me. She said, ‘let’s spend the night right here. Let’s not move.’ She said it playfully; and yet—I had the impression she was crying. I was about to turn her around, gently, so I could see. But something made me stop. It would have been an intrusion.”
Bark stopped. Frowned.
After a minute or two he continued.
“I said, I’d go anywhere and do anything with you because you are wonderful, but don’t you think it will be awfully uncomfortable—here? But she insisted, gently. ‘I really would like to do this, if you don’t mind. Please?’ She’s telling me, please. I couldn’t understand it, but what could I say?”
VII
“But there’s something you’re not telling me,” said Ed.
“Oh yeah?”
“That you fell in love with her.”
“I never said I didn’t.”
VIII
“So I put together some deep, square blue cushions I took from the armchairs in the reading-room at the front, and laid them out between the two book shelves where I’d found her. It was an absurdly uncomfortable bed, and two flights down to the bathroom. But of course it wasn’t so bad. In some ways it was very nice when I woke her at around two so we could make love again. The sense of total black in a huge unknown room all around us was wonderful. I felt her react when she came awake in the dark, her heart pulsing through the crisis of not knowing where she was, for just a second. She felt this huge volume all around her and I was her only reference point, and she clung to me, slightly trembling. And then she remembered.”
Bark is now resting his forehead on the window glass. His hands on his head, pulling his hair back and squeezing; rigid with tension.
But then he went slack and stepped back, sat down again; crisis over. Chatter returns. And then half-rising again Bark says, “Pardon me, excuse me,” to the crowd at large, in the embarrassed half-voice of a schoolboy who has just knocked over something noisy in mid-class, and doesn’t know whether he is supposed to apologize or vanish.
“Every year it gets harder for me to break away from this morbid self-consciousness,” he tells Ed, “this leech-like self-consciousness, even for a couple of seconds.”
“And then at dawn she put her lips against my cheek and said, half asleep, ‘fuck me again, please?’ And curled herself tighter. I told her, ‘that’s the sweetest thing anyone ever said to me.’ I meant it. The idea had been expressed many times before, but…” He stopped. “Never before with such…”
“Refinement?”
Bark glared. If you had laid a dagger in front of him, he would have plunged it into Ed’s heart.
“I’m sorry,” said Ed. “Go on.”
“Afterwards we both fell asleep, although we’d planned to make our escape early. But we were both awake again by seven thirty, and the place didn’t open until ten, so we had time.
“She found a coffee machine downstairs. And I turned up a tin of flat cinnamon crackers that I had overlooked last night. She served us coffee in our Styrofoam cups with the morning light purifying every surface it touched, on her knees, wearing only my unbuttoned sports jacket and the gold chain. Her smallish but beautiful breasts. Carefully, precisely smoothing back golden hairs as she bent over her task, picking up a Styrofoam cup and, holding it two inches in front of her pale, ample, left nipple, perfectly and precisely designed for my lips alone, she poured into it. She didn’t say too much during breakfast. But I was too blown away to care.
“You mean you were too recklessly, impetuously, little-girlishly in love to care?”
“Exactly. I wanted her very much. Very, very much. I wanted to have her forever.” Then, after a moment, “Do you think I could maybe get you to write my epitaph? My biography?”
“Your biography could be written in one sentence. Shall I write it now?”
IX
“Breakfast was done,” said Bark. “Garbage trucks hunkered past our front windows. We put everything back, cleaned up and had to get out of there—sneak out the basement door that led up to the parking lot in back. And naturally I said to her, ‘Can I see you tonight?’
She laughed, ‘I thought the idea was one place, one time—you wanted freedom, right?’
‘Yes, but you are not what I was counting on—I was wrong, you’re amazing—and admit it—I’m not what you were counting on either.’
‘Counting on? Yes I did not think you would come ravish me in the library. Professor.’
‘Let me take you to dinner.’
‘You had an experiment.’
‘We can have more.’
It’s important what was happening. She’s already halfway down the open stairway to the main floor and she’s stopped on the landing. I’d stapled her pants together, with tape on the inside; not a bad job. Her hand on her purse, purse strap over her shoulder. She‘s speaking quietly from the landing in the bell-clear morning, looking remarkably neat despite the hacked pants and hand-combed hair. She was completely self-possessed.
‘No,’ she said. ‘You had a plan.’
‘So what?’
‘If you are a man, you will follow through.’
‘Things change. People change. Why are you being so rigid?’
A chill went over her.
“'No,” she said, looking at me, concentrating hard on each word, as if she were steering a car around obstacles on a slippery road, “you cannot see me tonight. Or tomorrow. I’m not telling you my number or email and if you are decent, you will not try to find me.”
I said Why? but no sound came out.
“There would be no point.” She frowned and looked away. Then sudden pain seemed to grab her briefly—she flinched, gripped the bag strap tighter, dropped her eyes—breathing deeply as if to steady herself. I moved towards her, but she reached her arm out, flat palm towards me, resolute despite her slightly crumbling body. At last she said, “And because of Ophelia.”
She opens her mouth to say more but stops again, her fist clenched tight on the bag’s strap.
“Ophelia?” I say. I’m about to say, what is this? The tension is painful and I’m worried, suddenly she’s so different, so intense and off—and then she recites, quietly:
Quoth she, ‘Before you tumbled me,
You promis’d me to wed.’
He answers:
‘So would I ‘a’ done, by yonder sun,
An thou hadst not come to my bed.’
I have to think for a moment. Then, “And? Tamsin, what is wrong?”
“The first time I ever read that passage,” she said, “I was twelve.” Staring hard ahead as if her eyes don’t want to move. “I cried, it was so horrible. The cruelty. But why shouldn’t I walk out on a man the way he walked out on her—”
“He,” I said, “there is no he, this is a poem inside a poem—”
“But it’s real,” she said, “and you know it is!” An appeal—as if she were powerless to describe the vision that’s right before her eyes.
“But it’s fiction,” I said.
“Is it?” she asked; “is it really?”
And thinking back over this a million times, I am almost convinced that she was willing for me to say yes; and in my revolting stupidity, I hesitated. I hesitated. So she set off again….
“Wait, wait,” I say quietly, “what? What is this?”
I can hear tears looming but she presses on. “They always teach us that we are just pawns in your games. You play with us—well, you do—” She almost smiles. “But we play right back, it’s not like.” Serious eyes, deep breathing. “The fact is, we were nobody’s pawns, ever, I know bullshit when I hear it.” She looks at me defiantly, as if I had been telling her this stuff. “And so when I—”
“Wait, but—look, sure,” interrupting her, “but I personally have never ever thought, or taught, or said anything that—“Please please just wait….” But then she stops. Silence.
She’s swung her bag round to the front and is hugging it tight against her, absently; playing with the strap; her fingers tense and slow. “The Ophelia thing broke my heart.” She looked at the bag.
And I couldn’t rush down and scoop her up because every smallest move I made, she would flash her eyes over me and move one step farther down. Stumbling, once. So I stood still.
She frowned hard with the effort to stay focused, shuddering. “I cried my—cried my eyes out, I brooded and brooded and brooded about it till my stomach—it felt like I couldn’t breathe. I had these—ten-ton headaches—I could barely open my eyes. They took me to a doctor and then another but I needed a psychiatrist….”
“I’m not a vengeful person.” She looks at me briefly with oddly imploring eyes. “But I promised myself, I had to, that I—would—” She stops and looks up at me: she’s miserable. She shuts her eyes tight together, pauses, goes on: “That I would find a man to say it to one day, to horrify, to walk out on as if he didn’t exist—to know that men did it, and women did it, so I could forget about it. And I have. And I am so, so, so sorry!”
On a rising tide of tears she flings the “sorry” at me as if it were a million rose petals fluttering downward carpeting the floor where I stand—but she knows it isn’t enough, and shakes her head, looking downward, not meeting my eyes, in pure unhappiness.
Then at last she looks up and speaks out resolutely. “You tumbled me, and you are—you are a, you are a—” She stops.
“An asshole, a reptile?” I said. “A rapist?” I just wanted to survive.
“No!” she said with her eyes shut, “never! I was there! A man like you couldn’t rape a girl if he wanted to. But you still did…this. You didn’t even know me, not even a little…You saw me…we did it together. I gave myself. But I had told myself that if that ever happened—and I never thought it would—but if it did, I would walk out, as if it meant nothing—at all—nothing. What the hell is a plan if I don’t come through?” Getting mixed up in tears again. “Otherwise I might as well slit my wrists, because I would never trust myself ever again. I’m so, so sorry. Good bye.”
It was cruel of her and wasn’t fair and she knew it, except—I only wanted to rush down and hug her; and what she didn’t know was that, maybe, in a sense—she was not so completely unjust.
“Okay,” I have to tell her, “now you’ve told it to me, fine”—I’m speaking too quickly, and know that I am, it’s an emergency, an evil something is about to do away with me—“that’s fine, but it will not be fine if you don’t let me defend myself...”
And she looks up, breathless, straight at me.
The problem was, I did understand. If only I hadn’t. If only I had been quick enough to say I hadn’t.
She’s walked a few more steps down, and these stairs continue straight into the next-lower flight, where they end twenty feet from the exit door. I’m standing just a couple of steps from the top, thinking as fast as I can but feeling as if I can’t think at all.
“I like you,” she says. “But it’s not as if I can’t live without you!”
Then giving her head a stiff shake, she speaks her way onward. “This could have been a great moment. This could have been my big—” She’s wiping one hand downward across her eyes, her face disfigures into an ugly smile— “scene, my big triumph, my big smart-ass triumph, but instead you’ve made me so sad.”
“Let me just get hold of you for one second, please,” But “No” she says, and backs away again as I advance; “I ask you—you are a gentleman and in some sense a man, and not Ophelia’s bastard—“If I am, then, God, Tamsin, why can’t I see you just once more, please, if we could only just, only—”
“You made me like you very much, very very much. But nothing is free, and nothing is fair,” her eyes brimmed. “Oh I wish…If only…”
“But it’s all up to you! Up to you, only you, you!”
And then time stopped. She’s thinking. Her eyes gone vague, the image of misery, gigantic misery and yet—just for a few moments—it’s questioning misery, maybe misery, if-only misery—Time just stopped.
Stopped.
Stopped.
Stopped.
Finally she says, “Bark I am so, so—so—”
For an instant she is crying too hard to speak, and I’m saying ‘How can you throw all this out just for some abstract principle? I thought it was beautiful, the best thing I will ever know in my entire life. Is this so cheap to you? This real sympathy and friendship? It’s not just the goddamn sex. How can you—’ ‘Because’ she breaks in, low and urgent, ‘I have to. Be well, good—’ The bye gets lost in tears.
I said, ‘let me just kiss you good-bye!’ She turns, sprints to the door, throws her whole featherweight self against it, forces it open, patters up the concrete stairs outside as the heavy door sucks slowly closed and I hear ‘Forgive,’ from outside—pleading. Fading. Closed.
“No fire alarm.” Bart says. “I expected one. Must have been broken.”
“You didn’t follow her?”
“You see, if only I had said, marry me.”
Silence. Meanwhile the cups clinkled.
At last: “It would have worked then and only then, on the spot. I want to marry you, the Ophelia guy says, so sleep with me—great, except—hold on, you are now a whore, and so of course the deal is off. I mean, what do you take me for, madam? Instead I had to say, you did it for me, and just because of that I want to marry you, for that very reason—and she would have said no, but it would have made an impression, I think—if I had just said it without thinking, and the weird thing is—goddammit to hell. The thing is this.”
Studying the table intently as he brings the side of his hand down on it slowly, carefully. “I wanted to marry her.
“I did, right then and there.” As if he were describing a scene just barely visible in the distance. “I wanted acutely to marry her. She was the greatest girl I had ever met—I did want to marry her,” each word slow and distinct—“and I’d never felt that way before, I knew I wanted her forever and I would be good to her forever—and I said nothing. Nothing. Why not?” Speaking slowly, distinctly: “It just—didn’t—occur to me.”
He stopped.
“As if an executioner had said to me, ‘shall we just go ahead and hang you, then, sir? And it just didn’t occur to me to say, No thanks, not today. So they hanged me.”
Silence.
“We’re out of practice,” said Ed, “that’s all.” A pause to contemplate his own words. “In any case, saying just the right thing at the right time is never easy.”
Bark looked at the table and just barely shrugged. He had stepped out of the conversation. He barely showed any expression at all; he was right at sea level, looking at the waves eye-to-eye, watching the gulls sweep low.
“Marry me is different,” Bark said. “We’ve unlearnt it.” He was reporting (in a dead quiet voice) conclusions he’d clearly hit on long ago.
“You’re attributing your own pathology to everyone.” Ed was also talking as if he were reading a script. Something in the conversation had booted him off, too; far away. His shoulders moved as if he were having a bad dream.
They argued the point for a while by remote control. Each thinking about something else.
Bark looked away into an upper corner. He was sad.
“You tried to see her again,” said Ed, “but she wouldn’t? Or—something?”
Bark looked at the table and just barely shrugged.
“You put down the phone number, or drove right back to Connecticut without even stopping? Something like that?” He waited. Bark made no sign. “Because you do have a conscience of sorts. Although you wish you didn’t.”
“Don’t we all,” said Bark. “Who needs it?”
“Anyway: forget it. It’s too long ago to worry about now.”
Bark reached into his back pocket and pulled out his wallet and stuck two fingers deep into the tight space under the credit cards and pulled out, from way in back, two small blue earrings. Enamel octagons in gold frames. He cradled them in his hand. He was about to set them down on the table. But instead he just looked down at them, for a long time. Then he put them carefully away again.
A moment later, he dug into his right forward pocket and pulled out a classic chrome hip flask that Ed had never seen before—and he took a little sip and then a long drink. He was gasping afterward as he perched it on the table and then rammed it back into his pocket. His color changed. “When I say I’m a failure,” he said quietly, “believe it. Next time. I beg you. Believe it. If I’d only said what I actually meant, my whole life would have been different; but I didn’t.”
He stood. Dug around in one pocket, then another. Put three crumpled bills on the table. His face was flushed. He did not look Ed in the eye.
He nodded good bye, stood still for a moment, was about to move away when Ed put his hand across the table and took Bark’s wrist tight and said, after several moments of saying nothing, “I’m very sorry.”
He released the wrist.
“Thanks.” Bark gave an uneasy smile and, raising his arms, rested his interlaced hands on his head, looking at nothing.
Then, with hands on his head, he started walking unsteadily towards the door. Stiffly, between tables. The color was gone and he looked grim. “He seemed to find his way without his eyes,” Ophelia would have said. Couldn’t be drunk on one deep gulp, but he looked wrong; Ed watched for a moment and then followed him up, fast, and took him around the shoulders.
Ed looked for a chair but Bark moved relentlessly toward the door; they went out, and Bark walked fast across the little triangular flag-stone patio towards an open recycling bin. And vomited. Then again—and again—and then he somehow eased himself down flat on his ass, and was sitting on the flags, bent over, legs stretched out straight in front, with Ed crouched next to him. They stayed in just these positions as seconds passed and then minutes. People watched from inside.
At length Bark said, “I’m good. Thanks.” His shoulders rose, sank.
But he didn’t move.
“Take it easy,” said Ed.
“Who needs it,” Bark said. And then: “It’s not true. Conscience doesn’t make cowards of us all. Just total wrecks.” He smiled at himself dimly.
Slight breeze. Gorgeous day.

