I would not have very much interest in the enneagram if it were not for my friend the Platonist scholar. As a doctoral student in ancient philosophy at Stanford in his 40s, he is an unusual type who you may meet only a few times in your entire life, and each [subset] man in the type would be so unique, so fixed on self-reliance and self-determination, so hyper-individuated, that one would be hard-pressed to explore the ways they actually are the same type rather than unique to the point of surpassing the concept of type.
This scholar makes a compelling case that you can see elements of the enneagram throughout ancient literatures, and that there is something Platonic about it. (If you want to be enneagram typed by him, message.)
One of the key elements of the enneagram typing system is that people develop a strategy for living motivated by shame, anger, or fear, and then they (hopefully) (eventually) learn that living according to their set of rules for navigating these historic ailments that [boxes them in] might not be the best way to live among the options.
Your primary type is in the head (fear), the gut (anger) or the heart (shame), but every person has each of the nine numbers (three for each body energy center), in different ratios of priority. Thus the universality of the enneagram, and the universality of these three distinct pains.
The title of this piece is a reference to a chapter from Moby-Dick, “Of Whales in Paint; in Teeth; in Wood; in Sheet-Iron; in Stone; in Mountains; in Stars.” This is one of the chapters that goes into comprehensive and ambitious detail about the whale—the chapters that the book is notorious for, such as chapter 77 (“The Great Heidelburgh Tun”) which describes harvesting the waxy spermaceti fluid from the sperm whale’s head.
This chapter describes the various art forms that people have used to depict whales, which over history were so large that they could not actually be accurately depicted, because people would only see part of the whale; a skeleton, a back in the water, the whale fat. Before modern technology the animal was simply too massive to see all at once.
The depths of human pains are probably also too massive to see all at once. This is why I like the enneagram. You can look at a small element at a time, see how it contrasts with others. You can see how they form triangles, constellations, reconstellations. You can see how a pain you have has been felt by millions of people currently alive, and millions of people in history, and billions of mammals small and large.
If you collect the pain held in human hearts, in human livers, in human spleens, it would be the size of mountains.
In some ways this is beautiful. This is why I prefer Melville over Dostoevsky at what they each are famous for doing in making legible the content of man’s hearts. The size of the pain is colossal, and through literature about large enough objects in the world Moby-Dick succeeds in its attempt to catch it.


You are the first person to convince me I might not just like, but deeply adoreee reading Moby Dick.